Elite bodybuilders I've interviewed consume over 600 grams of protein daily, convinced that such a high intake drives muscle growth. But research suggests they may be wasting money—and stressing their kidneys. Studies consistently show the optimal protein intake for building muscle is just 1.7 grams per kilogram of body weight. For a 100-kilogram athlete, that's only 170 grams—less than a third of what many pros consume.
The protein obsession isn't entirely unfounded. Excluding water, muscle tissue is roughly 80% protein by dry weight. The Greek root of "protein"—proteios, meaning "of first rank"—reflects this primacy. But more isn't always better. The exception: extreme dieting. When calories or carbohydrates are severely restricted, protein needs nearly double to 3.3 grams per kilogram to preserve muscle mass.
Does high protein destroy your kidneys? It's one of nutrition's most persistent myths. The fear originated from studies of patients with existing kidney disease—people whose damaged nephrons (the kidney's filtering units) struggle to process protein's metabolic byproducts. In these patients, high protein intake accelerates decline.
But dozens of studies since—including meta-analyses of athletes consuming 2.5+ grams per kilogram daily—show that healthy kidneys can handle high protein intake without damage. Even the animal research that worried early researchers tells a reassuring story: rats fed excessive protein developed enlarged kidneys, but histological analysis revealed no pathological changes. The enlargement was compensatory hypertrophy—a normal adaptive response, like a muscle growing stronger under load.
The exception: if you have chronic kidney disease or a family history of kidney problems, consult a nephrologist before dramatically increasing protein intake. For everyone else with normal kidney function (confirmed by routine blood tests measuring creatinine and glomerular filtration rate), current evidence suggests high protein poses no renal risk.
Anabolic steroid users face an entirely different risk profile. Over the past decade, nephrologists have documented cases of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS)—a serious kidney scarring disease—in competitive bodybuilders. The suspected cause: a synergistic assault from high-dose steroids (often exceeding 1,000 mg weekly) and extreme protein intake (600+ grams daily).
Steroids amplify the problem through multiple pathways. They increase muscle protein synthesis, generating more nitrogenous waste for the kidneys to filter. They elevate blood pressure, forcing glomeruli to work harder. And they may cause direct podocyte injury—damage to the cells that maintain the kidney's filtration barrier. Add massive dietary protein, and you're asking kidneys to run a marathon while carrying a backpack full of bricks.
Join today and get access to this article and all past and present Newsletters, since September 2014. Each month you’ll get a new issue sent to your inbox. Subscribe today for only $10/month!